Did you know that only 75–85% of emails reach a user’s inbox? Or that sender reputation accounts for about 70–80% of deliverability issues?
Thousands of companies unknowingly suffer from sender reputation damage. Some overuse their primary domain, eventually leading to these issues. What if there were a way to repair this damage and put processes in place to prevent it from happening again?
That is where email domain rotation comes in. A straightforward tactic keeps your product’s email reputation high. The basic idea is to limit the amount of emails per day that a domain sends. Once you hit that limit, you can pivot to another domain and continue sending.
If your primary domain is myapp.com, you might also have myapp.io, myapp.xyz, myappmail.com, etc. For your cold outreach campaigns, you could rotate between myapp.io, myapp.xyz, and myappemail.com while keeping your primary domain reserved for transactional emails. But this is only the start—there’s much more to understand before putting email rotation into action.
First, it’s good to establish a basic understanding of the different categories of emails your application will use. From there, we can dive deeper into domain rotation and determine where it best fits your use case.
Let's categorize email types into three primary buckets: Transactional, Engagement, and Cold Outreach. There may be a few emails that fall outside these categories or blend between them, but generally, these three are fairly distinct in terms of purpose.
Transactional Emails
Transactional emails are triggered by in-app activities such as welcome emails, password resets, profile views, friend invites, and so on. These typically have high open rates because recipients expect them. It’s critical that these emails are sent from one of your most reputable domains, not impacted by riskier activities like cold outreach. Reputation for these emails is very important, which is why we encourage you to use your primary domain (e.g., myapp.com). If these end up in spam, your churn rate could skyrocket, which could lead to loss of revenue, decreased customer lifecycle and brand reputation.
Engagement Emails
The Engagement category includes non-transactional emails that encourage your existing audience to use your app. For example, you might send emails to inactive users with a holiday promo, or notify all users about a special event. We recommend using a subdomain on your primary domain for this category. Engagement emails carry slightly more risk than transactional emails, but far less than cold outreach.
Cold Outreach Emails
Cold outreach involves emailing people who haven’t yet signed up for your platform. These emails typically contain strong marketing hooks, sales pitches, and clear calls to action. They carry the highest risk for sender reputation, usually have the largest volume, and are most prone to landing in spam. Email vendors put a lot of scrutiny on cold outreach for several reasons:
-
High volume: Cold outreach emails are often bulk sends, and vendors know that.
-
Low open rates: Low engagement further signals to vendors that these might be spam.
Although you can use a subdomain for cold outreach, we’ve seen better results with completely separate domains (e.g., myapp.xyz, myapp.io). For large-scale cold outreach campaigns, five domains is a good benchmark.
Why Domain Rotation Matters
Domain rotation really only applies to the cold outreach category, because that’s where most sender-reputation risk lies. Transactional emails naturally receive a high reputation, they’re expected by recipients and therefore enjoy higher open rates. Engagement emails also perform decently because they target an existing user base. Thus, there’s less motivation to rotate domains for either of these categories. Keep transactional emails on your main domain and consider assigning Engagement emails to a primary subdomain.
How to Implement Domain Rotation
Now that we understand what domain rotation is and which emails benefit from it, let’s discuss how to use it.
-
Acquire 5 Similar Domains: Instead of myapp.com, you might pick myapp.io, myapp.xyz, themyapp.com, etc. Most email clients use sender labels, so users rarely notice the exact domain, just make sure links point to your primary domain for a consistent user experience.
-
Authenticate: Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for these domains. Most ESPs (e.g., SendGrid) guide you through this. Proper authentication is critical; without it, your emails will likely go to spam.
-
IP Reputation: Email vendors also factor in IP reputation. Many free or low-cost plans use shared IPs, where another sender’s bad practices could harm your reputation. For that reason, we recommend using a dedicated IP if possible. One dedicated IP can support multiple domains effectively.
-
Warm Up Your Domains: Start small, don’t send 10,000 emails on day one. Gradually build up your sending volume to establish trust. For example, send around 20 emails per day to engaged users during the first two weeks. Then increase to 20–50 per day by week 3 or 4. After that, 50–100 emails per day is usually safe. If you want to send 1,000 emails daily, you’ll need about 10 warmed-up domains.
-
Execution: Most ESPs (e.g., SendGrid, Postmark) support domain rotation. If you use a sales-focused CRM (e.g., Outreach, Salesloft), native rotation might be unavailable, but bolt-on solutions like SendSure.io can help. If you’re unsure about switching platforms, try rotating domains manually and measure the results to see if the payoff is worth the effort.
Measuring Results
After implementing domain rotation, monitor these key metrics:
-
Delivery Rate (Bounce Rate): Reflects how many emails actually reach inboxes. High bounces can hurt reputation.
-
Open Rate: Low open rates might signal spam issues or unengaging subject lines.
-
Click Rate: Useful if your emails contain CTAs; however, this is more about email content than deliverability.
-
In-App Metrics: Consider conversions, purchases, or subscriptions to track true ROI.
For domain rotation specifically, focus on open rates. Delivery rates depend more on list quality and bounces, while click-through rates hinge on your email content. If you see a 5–10% lift in open rates, domain rotation is typically worth the time and cost.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, successful domain rotation balances risk, reputation, and relevance. By distributing your email sends across multiple domains and carefully warming them up, you reduce deliverability pitfalls and protect critical messages like transactional emails. When you combine this strategy with a dedicated IP, proper authentication, and ongoing monitoring of key metrics (open rates, spam complaints, etc.), you set your email program up for success. With regular monitoring and data-based changes, domain rotation can protect your sender reputation. It can also help your product's emails reach more people.
Ready to Take Your App and Its Email Game to the Next Level?
For strong domain rotation or a partner to build and grow a top app, Rapptr Labs can help. We are the product development agency that created several award-winning apps. This includes two Google App of the Year winners. We understand how important email communication is for a smooth user experience. From strategic domain rotation to top-tier UX/UI and backend architecture, we bake a winning email strategy right into your product’s DNA.
Shameless Sale Alert: We’re here to help turn your vision into the next remarkable success story.
-
Domain Rotation & Deliverability Expertise: Keep your app’s emails in the inbox, not the spam folder.
-
Full-Service Product Development: We provide complete solutions that take you from an idea to a finished app. Our service includes strong infrastructure and award-winning design.
-
Proven Scaling & Growth: We help you handle fast-growing user bases without sacrificing quality or performance.
Let’s Chat
Make email deliverability easy and help your product win awards. It could even become the next “Google App of the Year.” Click here to tell us about your app idea or current challenge. We’ll be in touch to show you how Rapptr Labs can transform and scale your product—while keeping your inbox placement rates sky-high.